Aogami vs Shirogami: what is the difference between Blue and White steel?
Short answer: Aogami (Blue paper steel) is, in essence, Shirogami (White paper steel) with chromium and tungsten added. Both are very pure carbon steels made by Proterial, formerly Hitachi Metals, under its Yasugi Specialty Steel (YSS) name. In aogami vs shirogami, White sharpens fastest to the keenest edge, while Blue holds its edge longer. Neither is stainless, so both rust if left wet.
Key takeaways
- Both are YSS steels from Proterial, which was called Hitachi Metals until January 2023. The names come from the colour of the labels used to identify the steels at the factory: shirogami means white paper, aogami blue paper.
- Shirogami is a plain high-carbon steel with very low impurities. Aogami adds about 0.2–0.5% chromium and 1.0–2.5% tungsten, depending on the grade.
- The number shows the carbon content: No.1 has about 1.25–1.35% carbon, No.2 about 1.05–1.15% and White No.3 about 0.80–0.90%. Aogami Super has 1.40–1.50% carbon and adds vanadium.
- Tungsten carbides make Blue steel more wear-resistant, so it stays sharp longer but takes a little longer to sharpen. White steel is the quickest and most responsive on a whetstone.
- Neither steel is stainless: stainless needs roughly 10.5–12% chromium, and Aogami has well under 1%. Care for both the same way.
- The smith’s heat treatment, the hardness and the blade’s geometry matter as much as the colour of the steel.
What are Aogami and Shirogami steel?
Aogami and Shirogami are carbon steels made by Proterial, the Japanese company called Hitachi Metals until it changed its name in January 2023. They are sold under its YSS (Yasugi Specialty Steel) name, after Yasugi in Shimane Prefecture, and they are the best-known steels for traditional Japanese knives, used for everything from hand-forged gyuto to single-bevel fish knives.
The names are labels, not descriptions: the steels have long been identified at the factory by the colour of their paper labels. Shirogami (白紙) means “white paper” and Aogami (青紙) means “blue paper”. In English you will see White #2 or White steel, Blue #2 or Blue steel, and Aogami Super or Blue Super. Proterial also makes a Kigami (“yellow paper”) carbon steel.
Proterial describes the White steels as carbon steels with minimum impurities, and the Blue steels as alloy steels with tungsten and chromium added to improve their heat-treatment properties and wear resistance. Put simply, Blue steel is White steel with extra alloying.
Aogami vs Shirogami: what is in each steel?
Proterial publishes typical compositions for each grade. All six share the same base of 0.10–0.20% silicon and 0.20–0.30% manganese, with phosphorus held at 0.025% or below and sulphur at 0.004% or below. Those very low impurity levels are what Yasugi steel is known for.
| Grade | Carbon (%) | Chromium (%) | Tungsten (%) | Vanadium (%) | Proterial’s description |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Shirogami No.1 (White #1) | 1.25–1.35 | – | – | – | Carbon steel, highest hardness |
| Shirogami No.2 (White #2) | 1.05–1.15 | – | – | – | Carbon steel, high hardness |
| Shirogami No.3 (White #3) | 0.80–0.90 | – | – | – | Carbon steel, middle hardness |
| Aogami No.1 (Blue #1) | 1.25–1.35 | 0.30–0.50 | 1.50–2.00 | – | Tungsten-chromium alloy steel |
| Aogami No.2 (Blue #2) | 1.05–1.15 | 0.20–0.50 | 1.00–1.50 | – | Tungsten-chromium alloy steel |
| Aogami Super (Blue Super) | 1.40–1.50 | 0.30–0.50 | 2.00–2.50 | 0.30–0.50 | Tungsten-chromium-vanadium alloy steel |
Source: Proterial YSS steel data. A dash means Proterial lists no addition. Proterial gives a hardened hardness of 60 HRC or more for every grade; finished knives vary with the smith’s heat treatment. Our Sakamoto Santoku 165mm in Shirogami No.2, for example, is HRC 62±1.
Two patterns stand out. Each Blue grade has the same carbon range as the matching White grade, so Blue #2 is essentially White #2 plus chromium and tungsten, and Blue #1 is White #1 plus rather more of both. Aogami Super goes further on every count, with the most carbon and tungsten and an addition of vanadium.
What do tungsten and chromium change?
Tungsten forms very hard tungsten carbides. Metallurgist Larrin Thomas of Knife Steel Nerds explains that the wear resistance of tungsten-alloyed carbon steels is controlled mainly by how much tungsten carbide they contain, and that tungsten also keeps the grain very fine. More wear resistance means an edge that lasts longer, but, as he points out, ease of sharpening is the inverse of wear resistance.
Keep that in proportion. Knife Steel Nerds also notes that the Blue series is still not exceptionally wear-resistant compared with high-vanadium steels, so even Aogami Super sharpens far more easily than the high-vanadium powder steels used in some modern knives.
The small chromium addition mainly helps the steel harden: Knife Steel Nerds attributes the hardenability of these steels largely to chromium and manganese, with tungsten adding little. Chromium is often said to make Blue steel slightly slower to rust than White, but at well under 1% both are reactive carbon steels. Knife Steel Nerds puts the threshold for stainless steel at roughly 10.5–12% chromium.
How do Aogami and Shirogami compare in the kitchen?
| Property | Shirogami (White #1, #2) | Aogami (Blue #1, #2) | Aogami Super |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sharpening on whetstones | Fastest and most responsive | Easy; a little slower to refine | Slowest of the three, but still easy on good stones |
| Edge | Exceptionally fine and keen | Very keen | Very keen |
| Edge retention | Good; needs touching up more often | Longer, thanks to tungsten carbides | Longest of the three |
| Toughness | Lower-carbon White #2 (and #3) are the most forgiving | Slightly less forgiving than White at the same carbon, because of its extra carbides | Least forgiving: very high carbon lowers toughness |
| Rust and patina | Very reactive | Very reactive; perhaps slightly less so | As Blue |
| Best for | Keen sharpeners; traditional single-bevel knives | All-round gyuto, santoku, bunka and slicers | Enthusiasts who want maximum edge life |
Sharpening and edge retention
White steel is a pleasure on whetstones. It responds quickly, raises a burr readily and takes an exceptionally fine edge, which is why it appeals to people who enjoy sharpening. The trade-off is that the edge wears sooner, so expect to touch it up more often.
Blue steel is still easy to sharpen. Its tungsten carbides make it a little slower to bring to a final polish, and Aogami Super, with the most tungsten, is the slowest of the three. In return, Blue holds a working edge longer, and Aogami Super longest of all. Larrin Thomas has suggested that the Aogami steels should out-last 52100, a well-regarded carbon steel, for edge retention, with White #1 roughly comparable to it.
Toughness and chipping
Toughness depends more on hardness, heat treatment and edge thickness than on the colour of the steel, so treat any ranking with caution. In general, more carbon and more carbide mean less forgiveness. Knife Steel Nerds describes tungsten-alloyed carbon steels as “not stellar” for toughness and notes that very high carbon, as in Aogami Super, reduces toughness for little gain in wear resistance. The lower-carbon White grades, especially White #3, are the most forgiving.
In practice any of these steels, hardened above HRC 60 and ground thin, will chip if you twist the blade, hit bone or cut on a hard board. See Do Japanese knives chip easily? for how to avoid it.
Rust and patina
Both are reactive carbon steels. They rust if left wet and darken into a grey or bluish patina with use, especially after acidic or salty food. Care for both the same way: wipe during use, wash and dry by hand straight after, and oil before storing.
Many Aogami and Shirogami knives are clad, either in soft iron (the traditional choice, often with a kasumi or kurouchi finish) or in stainless steel. Stainless cladding confines the reactive steel to the edge bevel; soft iron is reactive too, so the whole blade needs care. Our guide to kurouchi, nashiji and tsuchime finishes explains the finishes you’ll see on these knives.
What do No.1, No.2 and Super mean?
The number shows the carbon content: the lower the number, the more carbon. No.1 grades can be hardened higher and hold an edge longer but are less forgiving. No.2 grades balance keenness, edge life and toughness. White No.3, with the least carbon, has the lowest hardness of the White grades and is the most forgiving.
Aogami Super adds even more carbon and tungsten than Blue #1, plus vanadium. It is the choice for maximum edge life, usually at high hardness from experienced smiths; Knife Steel Nerds recommends tungsten-alloyed carbon steels like this at around 64 HRC and above.
Does the maker matter more than the steel?
Often, yes. Proterial’s data shows White No.1 and No.2 water-quenched from a slightly lower temperature range than the Blue steels, which can also be oil-quenched. Water quenching is fast and demanding, which is one reason White steel rewards a skilled smith. A well heat-treated White #2 knife from a good maker will usually out-perform a poorly made knife in a “better” steel.
Geometry matters just as much: a thin, well-ground White #2 blade can cut more easily than a thick Aogami Super one. When you compare knives, look at the maker, the hardness they quote and how the blade is ground, not just the colour of the steel. Our steel chemistry guide covers the other steels we sell, and our blacksmiths profile introduces the makers.
Which should you choose?
- Choose Shirogami (White) if you sharpen on whetstones, want the keenest possible edge and don’t mind touching it up often, or you want a traditional single-bevel knife. Try the Sakamoto Santoku 165mm (Shirogami No.2, three layers, kurouchi finish, HRC 62±1; under £70 at the time of writing, October 2026) or Sakamoto Nakiri 165mm, the Tanaka Shiro 2 Bunka 180mm or Tanaka Shiro 2 Gyuto, or, for fish, the Sakai Traditional Deba (Shirogami No.2, two layers, single bevel, kasumi finish, 150/165/180mm).
- Choose Aogami No.2 (Blue #2) for an all-rounder that stays sharp longer: the Pateru Aogami 2 Santoku 165mm or the Pateru Aogami 2 Sujihiki 225mm for slicing.
- Blue steel under our own label: the JKC Aogami Gyuto (two sizes) and JKC Aogami Santoku 170mm.
- Choose Aogami No.1 for a harder, higher-carbon Blue steel: see our Tanaka Aogami 1 collection.
- Choose Aogami Super for maximum edge life in a hand-forged knife: the Takeda 3 Layer range, including the Takeda 3 Layer Bunka 175mm.
- Don’t want to wipe and dry as you cook? Choose stainless, such as VG10. See Is a carbon steel knife worth it for a home cook? and Is VG10 a good steel for kitchen knives?
How Japanese Knife Company can help
Blue and White steel feel different on the stone and in use, and the best way to choose is to hold both. In our London shops you can try knives with guidance in our knife studio; find addresses and opening hours on our shops page.
Every knife bought from us comes with one complimentary sharpening. After that, our whetstone sharpening and repair service, at Baker Street, Greek Street, Kensington, Chiswick and Wimbledon or by post, costs £1.35 per inch for domestic double-bevel knives and £2.25 per inch for domestic single-bevel knives, with rust removal from £6. To sharpen carbon steel yourself, our two-hour, hands-on knife sharpening class is designed for beginners, with no more than six people per group, and a 1000/6000 combination stone is a good first stone for either steel.
Related questions
- What is the difference between stainless steel, carbon steel, VG10, AUS10, Aogami, Shirogami, SG2/R2, and Damascus steel?
- Is a carbon steel knife worth it for a home cook?
- How do I sharpen a Japanese knife on a whetstone?
- Will my Japanese knife rust, stain, or develop a patina over time?
- Is a hand-forged knife better than a machine-made one?
Sources
- Proterial (YSS) – Shirogami 2: typical chemical composition and heat treatment
- Proterial (YSS) – Aogami 2: typical chemical composition and heat treatment
- Proterial (YSS) – Aogami Super: typical chemical composition and heat treatment
- Knife Steel Nerds – Is Blue Super Steel Actually Super? The Facts About Tungsten-Alloyed Steels
- Knife Steel Nerds – How to Pick the Best Steel for Every Knife
Reviewed by the Japanese Knife Company team, October 2026.